Chocolate Chip
A timeless favorite made with rich brown sugar dough and loaded with melty semi-sweet chocolate chips.
Order
Let’s make life sweet
Cardinal
Cake Co.
Small-batch cookies and custom cakes, baked by hand in Farmington, Arkansas.
The cookie lineup
The Cookie Menu
Baked fresh in Farmington.
Nationwide shipping coming soon!
Chocolate Chip Pecan
Our classic chocolate chip cookie packed with toasted pecans for the perfect buttery crunch.
Order
Toffee Pecan Chocolate Chip
Our chocolate chip cookie with buttery toffee bits and toasted pecans for a sweet, crunchy finish.
Order
Brookie Cookie
The best of both worlds. Fudgy brownie meets chewy chocolate chip cookie in one decadent, brownie filled bite.
Order
Cosmo Brownie
A rich chocolate cookie with chocolate chips and M&M’s, topped and filled with a Cosmic Brownie bite. Inspired by the nostalgic lunchbox treat.
Order
Lemon Drop
A soft, bright lemon cookie bursting with fresh citrus flavor and white chocolate.
Order
Banana Pudding
A soft banana cookie filled with creamy vanilla goodness and nostalgic banana pudding flavor in every bite.
Order
Snickerdoodle
A soft, buttery cookie filled with cinnamon sugar with a perfectly cozy flavor and chewy center.
Order
Cookie Butter
A warm spiced cookie made with creamy cookie butter and Biscoff cookies for a rich caramelized flavor that’s impossible to resist.
Order
Circus Animal
A vanilla sugar cookie packed with crunchy frosted circus animal cookies and colorful sprinkles for a fun childhood favorite.
Order
Strawberry Pop Tart
A buttery strawberry cookie inspired by the classic breakfast treat, bursting with sweet strawberry flavor and white chocolate.
Order
Peanut Butter Chippy
A thick, soft peanut butter cookie loaded with melty white chocolate chips and peanut butter chips for the ultimate sweet and salty combo.
Order
M&M
A classic chewy cookie packed with colorful chocolate candies in every bite.
Order
Butterfinger Blast
A chewy chocolate chip cookie loaded with crunchy Butterfinger pieces for a peanut buttery candy bar finish.
Order
Vanilla Sprinkle
A soft vanilla sugar cookie filled with colorful sprinkles and white chocolate for a simple, sweet celebration.
Order
Birthday Cake
A funfetti-inspired vanilla cookie bursting with colorful sprinkles, buttercream icing, crunchy vanilla cookies, and sweet birthday cake flavor.
Order
Stuffed Nutella Chocolate Chip
Our classic chocolate chip cookie stuffed with a gooey center of creamy Nutella.
Order
Coconut Caramel Chocolate Chip
A chewy chocolate chip cookie filled with toasted coconut and buttery caramel.
Order
Cookies + Cream
A soft vanilla cookie packed with chocolate sandwich cookie pieces and creamy white chocolate.
Order
Butterscotch Chocolate Chip
Classic chocolate chip dough loaded with rich butterscotch morsels for the perfect balance of sweet and buttery.
Order
The Everything Cookie
If you can’t decide, this one’s for you! Loaded with chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, coconut, crunchy pretzels, and toasted pecans for a little bit of everything.
Order
The Cardinal
Our signature red velvet cookie with a rich red velvet cake pop tucked inside for an unforgettable surprise in every bite.
Order
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
A soft and hearty oatmeal cookie filled with melty chocolate chips for the perfect comforting classic.
Order
Love Story
A dreamy wedding cake cookie. Almond flavored and stuffed with moist wedding cake for a sweet love story in every bite. Inspired by the T+T “Love Story.”
OrderLocal?
Visit The Cookie Porch
Self-serve on our front porch
Cookies Monday - Friday 7am-8pm
Variety Pop-Up on Saturday 8am-8pm
Closed Sunday
Made to order, locally
Cakes & More
Everything below is baked to order and picked up in Farmington at your designated time.
Send an inquiry and Rachel will plan it with you.
- Custom CakesDesigned for weddings, birthdays & showers
- Cookie CakesDecorated, always a hit
- Gourmet Cookies & BrookiesOur best sellers, by the dozen
- Party CrackersA signature crowd-pleaser
- CupcakesBakery-style, by the dozen
- Pies & Seasonal TreatsFrom-scratch, ask what’s baking
Our mobile cake bar
The Trolley
Our mobile cake bar, rolled straight to your wedding or big event, where every guest gets to design their own mini cake with Rachel. Pick the cake flavors, buttercreams, and toppings, then watch it come together.
Check Availability“We can’t even describe the talent that went into our wedding cake. She hit it perfectly in every detail, and we even had people that don’t eat cake bragging about how good it was.”
Wedding client“Attended a wedding with The Trolley set up at the venue. It was so much fun and a huge hit, and the cake was delicious!”
Wedding guest“My husband ordered a cookie cake for my birthday and it was absolutely beautiful and sooo delicious! And the service was top-notch.”
Birthday order“I ordered a Valentine’s cake for my kiddos and holy moly, it was the best tasting cookie cake I have ever had!”
Valentine’s order“Have shopped with her multiple times. Always fantastic, and we look forward to seeing what she thinks of next. Definitely a family favorite.”
Repeat customer“Rachel has made birthday cakes, fruit pizzas, and numerous boxes of cookies for us. Everything is beautiful and delicious, and she is so sweet and easy to work with.”
Longtime customer
Our story
Meet Rachel
Hi there! I’m Rachel, owner and baker behind Cardinal Cake Co. I’ve been baking for over sixteen years, and when my family moved to Farmington in 2021, a few cakes for neighbors quickly grew into a full-time business doing what I love most.
Every cake, cookie, and treat is made with care, joy, and a whole lot of love. Thank you for letting me be part of your celebrations.
Let’s make life sweet, one treat at a time.
Get in touch
Start an Order
Cakes, The Trolley, or custom orders.
Send a few details and Rachel will reach out!
- 479-831-5797Call or text
- Rachel.cardinalcakeco@gmail.comEmail
- Instagram@cardinalcakecoar
- Facebook@cardinalcakecoar
-
Porch Stand: Farmington AR
216 S Amber Dawn Ave, Farmington, AR
Mon-Fri 7am-8pm
Variety Pop Up Saturday 8am-8pm
Closed Sunday
